While waiting to talk with a co-teacher yesterday, I was observing her teaching style and the differences in the way she teaches and the way I remember being taught in kindergarten. The one thing that really struck me was the way that children here are singled out in front of the whole class when they do something wrong or something looked down upon.
While I was watching yesterday, for example, one of the little boys was crying. I am going to explain to you what happened to the best of my ability, but I want you to remember that most of it took place in Chinese, so my translation might not be completely correct.
The teacher told the boy to come up to the front of the classroom and asked why he was crying. While he was sobbing, he said something, but I could not understand his answer. At first, the teacher seemed to be very understanding and it seemed to me like she was trying to console him. However, this entire time he was in front of the class crying, which is not the first place I would want to be if I were crying.
The next event that occured completely took me by surprise. She had the children chant, "You don't cry", while pointing to the boy (that part was in English, so I definitely understood it). She then had the boy go back to his seat and explained in Chinese that boys should not cry. So then my question is: if it had been a girl, would the same thing have happened, would they still have chanted "You don't cry", or are girls allowed to cry?
This was surprising to me for many reasons. First of all, I am not used to pointing children out in front of the class like that. It seems very harsh, especially for that grade level. Second, it surrpised me because I had thought that the times in which boys (especially six year old boys) were not allowed to cry and were taught in school to hide their emotions like that were over. I guess that this is still taught, perhaps even in the United States. Maybe I am just naive. What do you think? Do you think that this is still taught in the United States? Do you think it should be taught? To only boys or to both boys and girls? I would love to hear your opinions!
Understanding Loan Guarantee Program
13 years ago